Aaron Huddleston
Guest Columnist
September 16, 2005
Lisa Reisert boards a red-eye flight back to Miami only to find herself seated next to a terrorist who needs her help for his latest assignment. Sounds like the plot line for an amazing film, doesn't it? It sounds like it would play on some of the deepest fears of all Americans, hold us on the edge of our seats, make our hearts pound in our chests, make us grab the seatback in front of us until our knuckles turn white and leave us terrified to set foot on a plane, right?
That’s what I thought. With Wes Craven behind the wheel, the movie “Red Eye”
promised to be a great thriller. However, this film proved far less satisfactory
than its premise and director promised.
The storyline for this film was good. Reisert (Rachel McAdams) is a manager at a
hotel in Miami, Fla. After her grandmother's funeral, Lisa boards a red-eye
flight back to Miami. On this flight she is seated next to Jackson Ripner (Cillian
Murphey), a man who works with terrorists in government overthrows and
assassinations. Ripner informs Reisert that if she doesn’t help him by getting
the hotel to move a high-ranking government official to a certain room, he will
have her father (Brian Cox) killed. In all, this is a good story.
The cinematography was mediocre. The movie contained one or two good shots, a
few unique and interesting shots, but also many awkward shots. It also failed to
set a mood for the movie. The movie felt just matter-of-fact. There was no
suspense, no fear, no intrigue in the mood set by the cinematography of this
film.
The acting was the only part of this film that I can speak exceptionally highly
of. Rachel McAdams is the perfect heroine. She is strong, courageous and
intelligent. At the same time, however, she is vulnerable. She makes it easy for
the viewer to feel for her and root for her.
Murphey is amazing as the villain of this film. He puts you at ease, makes you
like him and then turns around and becomes truly disgusting. His character’s
creepiness comes not from how freaky or weird he is. Instead, his creepiness
comes from how frighteningly normal he is. Murphey brilliantly blends the normal
exterior of the character with the evil that lurks beneath the surface.
In the end, I give “Red Eye” 2 stars out of 5. To say the acting was too good
for the film, as I know many reviewers have already said, would be an
understatement. A promising story was crippled by terrible cinematography.
Brilliant acting was devalued by poor directing. A film with great potential was
squashed and became a terrible film. Craven didn’t live up to his reputation on
this attempt.
If you are looking for a good laugh, “Red Eye” might be a film to see. I found
myself laughing hysterically at portions of the film that weren’t supposed to be
funny. If, however, you are looking for a thriller, avoid this Wes Craven flop
at all costs. Better luck next time, Wes.