The mother of all controversies: New Scholarship arouses discussion on stipulations


Missie Mills

Reporter

Since its introduction via the fall Milligan Magazine, a new scholarship funded by 11 recent Milligan graduates has been a hot topic of discussion in many circles on campus.


Titled by its 11 alumni creators, “The Mother Of All Scholarships” is a $250 bookstore credit for the recipient’s final senior semester.


According to the Milligan Magazine, the scholarship “is intended for a senior male majoring in business or accounting. The funds are to be used to purchase books during the student’s last year at Milligan.”


Vice President for Institutional Advancement Todd Norris said the alumni who created the scholarship, “all lived in Kegley and they want to help current Milligan students similar to themselves.”


The controversy surrounding the scholarship is grounded in its stipulations. Applicants must be senior males who live in Kegley and are business or accounting majors. Some think it is unfair to be so limiting.


One member of the faculty who wished to remain anonymous said, “The Mother of All Scholarships flies in the face of the Milligan College mission statement.”


The missions statement reads, “As a Christian liberal arts college, Milligan College seeks to honor God by educating men and women to be servant-leaders.”
The faculty member said that the words “servant-leaders” are mocked by the scholarship.


Several members of the faculty and staff have expressed concern about the scholarship but did not wish to comment.


Kegley Associate Professor of Economics and Business Chair Bill Greer pointed out that not everyone is qualified for every scholarship, and The Mother Of All Scholarships is no more exclusive than scholarships determined by major, gender or county.


“That’s just the way scholarships are,” said Robert Mahan, Associate Professor of Accounting. “It was their choice to do that.”


According to Norris, the benefactors of the scholarship developed a brochure that “reflected their views (about the scholarship).”


“I think it is intended to be a funny thing,” Norris said.


One of the biggest complaints about the scholarship is how it was first introduced through the brochure the graduates made and submitted to the Advancement Office.


“I think the big issue is the brochure,” said Norris, “It was stated exclusively instead of inclusively,” Norris said. “As far as I know, they are not being exclusive. They are being inclusive to people who have a similar Milligan experience. They are wanting to reach out to students who think like they do.”


Norris said that the brochure, which is no longer being used by the advancement office, was not written by anyone at the college, so it did not hold the sensitivity that most scholarships written by the college have. The Advancement Office plans on creating a new brochure for distribution.
“The stipulations here are more extensive,” Norris said.


Mahan said that such stipulations are a customary thing.


“It’s the way you have to do it to make sure the money goes to the people you want it to.” Mahan said.
Norris feels there has been a “misinterpretation of the intent” of the scholarship.


“The motivation is that they are very recent graduates--young alums that want to give back. They really want to help current Milligan students.”


Norris said that when the alumni presented the scholarship to the Advancement Office, it was thoroughly concieved.


“(The Advancement Office) didn’t want to be discouraging, but probably should not have given them the leeway,” Norris said


Norris said he did not “anticipate the level of concern” the scholarship has brought.


According to the Milligan Magazine, to apply for the Mother Of All Scholarships, males must “submit an essay on the topic of the benefactors’ choosing. The benefactors, in conjunction with the business faculty, will then select the recipient